08 Nov 2007

Serial Experiments Lain

My first taste of Ghost Hound has reminded me of an old fave that had led me to it (and Kino’s Journey) in the first place - Nakamura’s Serial Experiments: Lain. It has long held a special place in my collection for being my first experience with ‘arty’ anime and undoubtedly set my viewing on its course that was destined to be littered with headscratcher titles. It was - and in my view still is - a landmark production that leads us to question technology and our perception of reality; at the same time it occasionally gets panned for being obtuse and overrated.

The world outside the Wired

I agree that it’s obtuse but for those of us who dig the whole deep and meaningful thing, Lain is a classic in every sense. A very important aspect to its appeal I think was the involvement of Yoshitoshi ABe in the designs for the characters and other artwork - Nakamura and Konaka provided the cryptic storyline and distinctive narrative structure but ABe’s input added the icing on the proverbial cake. The atmosphere of the show, almost as important as its themes and ideas at times, is largely attributed to ABe’s unique art style; I was so impressed with his skills that I hunted down the recent reissue of the Lain artbook, in hardback no less. His approach evolved independently from the standard methods of learning how to draw and design for anime and manga, which gave an effect akin to a classically-trained musician lending his or her talents to a rock band. The end result is that it’s different, refreshing and it sets itself away from similarly themed efforts.

Lain makes great use of atmospherics in creating a sensation of confusion and unease, which ABe’s artwork is in no small part responsible for. As I recently suggested, it’s almost a horror serial for the technological age; speculation and gossip concerning weird goings-on in the online world of the Wired win out over definite answers, with deaths and disappearances going on without a full explanation. As Dennou Coil recently has done, albeit in a more playful and light-hearted way, Lain explores the possibilities when the online world and the real world collide and the dividing line blurs; as the Matrix trilogy did soon after it even goes as far as challenging how we define what is real and what is the product of our imaginations and technological endeavours.

I'm in your internets, stealing your sanity

With the likes of the Matrix movies, Dennou Coil and the Ghost in the Shell franchise famously covering similar territory and doing it so well, it’s easy to dismiss Lain as another pretentious show to jump on the science fiction bandwagon. I disagree. If anything, it sits alongside these titles in highlighting the importance of computers and the internet on modern society; looking back at the state of things back when Lain was first broadcast back in 1998, the ‘net was already well established but had only recently begun to take off in a big way. The mythology, subcultures and the extensive move into everyday life that we see the Wired undertake are not only an observation of the WWW’s impact on our own world, but a prediction that turned out to be strangely prophetic. As with Oshii’s 1995 Ghost in the Shell movie, Lain’s worldview has not become out of date; if anything, it has become more relevant with the intervening years.

As well as being a sci-fi/cyberpunk piece, SE: Lain is also a philosophical and even theological one. Unlike, say, Evangelion, which uses stuff such as religious symbolism and Freudian psycholanalysis in a very simple way to support other ideas, Lain combines issues surrounding introspection and identity, Jung’s Collective Memory, Roswell and other conspiracy theories and a whole myriad of others in a way that is chillingly convincing. You can take away simple messages, such as the importance of family and friends or the motives and consequences of immersing oneself in imaginary environments and walk away satisfied; on the other hand there’s a whole treasure trove of highbrow ideas that are lurking under the surface, ready to be unearthed for people who like to read between the lines. Of all the headscratchers I’ve seen to date, this show offers the most complex array of baffling details and the largest degree of rewatchability - you can see it a number of times and still discover something new.

computer rig ownage

It is quite simply one of the most important pieces of anime I’ve seen, period. Admittedly the quality of the art is let down a bit by the animation (it comes across as a bit over-ambitious in that sense) and the characters interact in a way that is pretty cold and difficult to relate to. The latter point can probably be explained by the fact that it’s supposed to portray a world that’s more isolated and soulless than our own but there’s no denying some viewers will be put off by this. I never had a problem with the animation though since it comes across as so different - occasional moments are reminiscent of Anno-isms and the soundtrack has a very industrial and minimalist vibe to it. Sometimes the buzz of distant conversation or the ever-present hum of telephone lines says it all - it does a masterful job of portraying its worldview, as frightening and inhospitable as it can sometimes be.

The episodes are referred to as ‘layers’; a term that is perfectly appropriate given the numerous levels of meaning and significance that obscure and conceal; there’s no filler material to speak of and mystery builds upon mystery before the terrifying finale and a startling denoument that follows, reiterating the importance of friendship, communication and sense of who we are. It is alleged that the creative team were surprised and even mildly disappointed that audiences at home and abroad drew similar conclusions from the series. While that is less interesting from a cross-cultural study standpoint (as in: how do attitudes to computers and technology differ in Japan when compared with the West and so on), it highlights how Lain’s themes and ideas are universal. Favouring thought over action, realism over fan service, it’s an audacious and startlingly unique effort that deserves to be widely seen and widely remembered.

8 Replies

  1. BrikHaus

    Lain is really a great series. It’s funny you should bring it up, because I have been considering rewatching it. Maybe after Ghost Hound is over, I’ll watch it. I can only handle so many “hard to figure out” series at once.

  2. Mike

    It really is the most theological as well as intellectually coherent anime I’ve seen yet. (I have Haibane Renmei but haven’t watched it yet.) I’ve written about it in a years-old post I recently revived, and it’s still one of my favorite reflections on anime. May this tribe of anime increase.

  3. Mike

    Oh wait, that’s right. You actually commented on that post! Sorry about that.

  4. j.valdez

    It’s shows like Lain that keep me interested in anime. I bought the series a while back, but haven’t found the time to rewatch it. Like most others I’ve acquired, I never know when I’ll be able to rewatch the entire thing.

    It’s funny how the Matrix, Ghost in the Shell, Lain, among others come up with regard to Dennou Coil. I brought them up as well when I wrote about that show.

    It really is a primal fear of the unknown. People can postulate about whether human consciousness can be boiled down to something as simple as a Turing machine, substrate dependent, or how/if the soul plays a part. The common factor is that people are unwilling to simply let the unknown be un-known. With the willingness to guess at answers comes the hopes and fears that drive the illusions in a series like Lain.

  5. ConcreteBadger

    @Brikhaus: I know what you mean. Ghost Hound will provide all the head-scratchery I need in the coming weeks! It’s always nice to have a show like that in your viewing schedule, just to give your brain a workout.

    @Mike: Yeah, I really enjoyed your article since it highlights the spiritual side of the show. I’ve always seen it as a sci-fi story but there’s more to it than that, as I found out.

    @j.valdez: as much as we can push ahead with technological advances, there’s no escaping the fact that deep down, we’re still the same. One aspect of Lain that makes it so unsettling I think is when this creates a clash - there are still some things that we can’t quantify and categories into neat little lines of 1s and 0s.

  6. dm

    I always thought Lain’s “layers” were allusions to the ISO seven-layer framework for network communications — not as geekery, but because the term is evocative.

    Lain appeared in 1998, but I think the seeds of a lot of its sensibility were planted a couple of decades earlier, in the era of John Lilly and Ted Nelson and the Whole Earth Software Review: the first flush of the computer-utopians (for a glimpse into some of this era, take a look at John Markoff’s What the dormouse said, though, even better if you can find it, Ted Nelson’s Dream Machines/Computer Lib or Stewart Brand’s Two cybernetic frontiers. Lain is more of a computer dystopia, but the blending of the psychic and the cybernetic that was used in Lain echoes a lot of that stuff (and John Lilly is even mentioned in the series, as I recall).

    The other thing that always struck me about Lain is its unique look. Lain was still done with cel animation for its characters, but a good deal of the series was done with CGI in a way that was an improvement on most of the series that came after. You get the impression of real artists exploring the capabilities of new tools to produce a look that was both unique and uniquely appropriate to the series.

  7. ConcreteBadger

    @dm: that’s a nice reading list there - I’ve been a fan of P K Dick and Arthur C Clarke so I’m willing to check out some speculative sci-fi. From what I’ve heard, Lain’s creative team were particularly well-read so the series no doubt borrows from a lot of disparate sources. It’s pretty mind-boggling really!

    In trying to estimate how long Lain was in the planning stage for, I’d guess that the seeds were sown in the mid 90’s, or possibly even earlier - perhaps the spiritual aspect came first, then the Wired was added to the concept later on as the internet made itself known.

    I’m glad you appreciated the artwork too - for some reason it gets criticised quite a lot, which I think isn’t quite fair when it’s so innovative and pretty good quality for its time.

  8. Serial Experiments Lain and the Digital Flesh « Rahimyr’s Weblog

    [...] Martin Under, (2007), ‘Serial Experiment Lains,Retrived on 15 May, 2008:http://www.concretebadger.net/blog/2007/11/08/serial-experiments-lain/ [...]


Leave a Reply

Quicktags: